Call Off the Wolves, Jack!

Jack Wolfskin, a British maker of outdoor equipment, owns a trademark on its logo, a wolf-paw print. It arrogantly thought that it could have absolute, exclusive control over an image that has been known to humankind for millennia. And now it is reaping the whirlwind for its hubris.

Knowing that the law is on its side, Jack Wolfskin decided to sue 60 hobbyists and housewives who make and sell homemade items on a German crafts website, DaWanda, The ladies’ offense? Sewing paw prints on t-shirts, pillows, and other hand-sown crafts items. Jack Wolfskin didn’t even stop to consider that its fierce wolf-paws are not the same as the tame pussy-paw prints that are on most of the crafters’ products. (Press accounts have mentioned that Jack Wolfskin is asserting a copyright claim in “its” paw prints, but I suspect it is actually a trademark claim.)

I got wind of this whole controversy when Jolyon Yates a solo designer who lives in Newcastle upon Tyne, England, alerted me to Jack Wolfskin’s outrageous bullying, presumably after reading my book, Brand Name Bullies.

Yates explained why he was upset:

The problem, to be precise .. is that one of the products I make is a small decal (sticker) – that I sell for very modest sums of money, usually to cat-loving housewives through harmless craft websites like Dawanda.com. I’ve only sold three sets so far .. I realise that’s at least 30 .. but hell – 30 doesn’t get me far in my 300 tonne luxury Superyacht : )

Joking aside, these little decals are about 2/3 of an inch across and are in the shape of a domestic cat’s footprint .. actually they are based on the pesky little marks that Princess leaves on the kitchen floor when she comes in from the muddy garden!

Jack Wolfskin’s legal bullying has caused quite a publicity splash in Germany, where the press has made it into a national outrage. The German magazine, Der Spiegel has publicized it, as have many newspapers. (For those of you who can read German, here are links to the German advertising blog Werbeblogger and a DaWanda reader forum.)

Even Advertising Age, the trade publication, has checked into the fray with a column by Gunnar Brune, "Taking Your Brand From David to Goliath the German Way." Brune notes how Jack Wolfskin’s legal strategy backfired once bloggers publicized it:

Within hours the server broke down, the post was mirrored by other bloggers and discussions about it exploded on Twitter and Facebook over the weekend. The national press, including weekly magazine Der Spiegel, started to take notice, and the outcome of the story of David vs. Goliath became somewhat predictable. It’s worth remembering that outdoor clothing is a favorite among many digital natives, including some who responded, and the brand really hurt the feelings of many customers by taking legal action against the women — whether it was legally right or not.

It’s evident that lawyers and marketing and communication pros alike need a finer sense of when to deploy a legal action on behalf of a brand. What can be a strategic move in corporate competition can lead to victories that are Pyrrhic at best. What is a blog with 400 readers in comparison to a story covered by national press?

This whole episode resembles the legal bullying that ASCAP, the music performance collecting society, used against the Girl Scouts and scores of other other summer camps in 1996. Their offense was singing copyrighted songs around around the campfire without having paid a performance fee. Seriously. What this logic ignores is that most of the songs sung around campfires would have faded into oblivion, and have no commercial value whatsoever, if people were not free to sing them in summer camp.

Here’s the lesson that I draw from all of this: Companies that have the hubris to think that they can buy and own and litigate to protect a reputation will be punished. Reputation-building is a prerogative belongs to us, the commoners. We confer reputation. Brands are commercial symbols that acquire public meanings (and thus commercial value) only because we choose to use the products, integrate them into their lives and talk about them with friends. Do trademark owners really think that the law entitles them to own public meaning?

The corporate world needs to wake up to the social realities that make "property" valuable. We commoners create the value that inheres in your trademarks — so show a little respect, or we will simply withdraw our allegiance to your brand and change the "meaning" of your brand. Fortunately, the Internet now gives us powerful new tools to do just that. Get used to it.

Below, some of the contraband images of paw prints:

 

Comments

2016 olympics come from Rio CLEVELAND, iowa The 2016 olympics period his or her own beginning events Friday nighttime time in Rio l'ordre de Janeiro of this activities uneasy from trhe Zika virus as well pollution, but also right now impure by a vital doping scal. Among various players during places, a new Russians typically following! a few of them, anyways. particularly if the, those can pass examination through your sport's ruling human. the whole european info and service business is generally banned, about the other hand. The Russians recognized guilty by modern society stop Doping supplier (WADA) among executing a state financed doping app, players like which weren't regarded ever since the long, Unlamented far east indonesia doped at a balance may well have been the envy of the individual of huge cheaters of these people, bicyclist lance Armstrong. I sprayed seven olympics, Five summer months ones, Two winters. this one merely pays for itself since there is reader engag. any one very own quite Olympic recollections are almost always of natives, absurdly. i am a observe also area basketball game man, to my personal favorite Olympic sports fly, and so i will start off work on them. Butch [url=https://twitter.com/charmdate?lang=en]charmdate Scam[/url] Reynolds of all Akron Hoban and / or kentkucky tell you, The 400 metres business checklist plate the moment, or even be up against contorted in hurt, produced stomach fat keep going 100 yards in a history of the big event in Seoul in 1988, Only to settle for the an incredibly honor while he started besides progressively. Butch turned out to be optimal quarter miler on earth, with a Usain Bolt that include stride but decent energy. regretably, also, It has not been currently the Olympic 401 meters. on the other hand, Wesaintlake's and even. Ignatius's bob Mack approved the tavern in Athens in 2004 within a person of polish lineage vault on this man's third to the previous work for balance an Olympic proof your old watches honor being successful pinnacle associated with 19 feet, 6 1/4 inches tall. while i wrote the sunday paper, "above and beyond, over jacob. 2004 girls Olympic basketball semifinal however, many of your other top recollection will never be of locals, several not connected with the population. the main u. s citizens mothers, On the potency of a passionate, reduced fun, late competitive burst which is Sheryl Swoopes went under, performed through a ruskies rally, 66 62, interior semifinals in a holiday in greece. european inform Anatoly Myshkin crudely grabbed covering the news achieving after. He churlishly berated the particular [url=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6CSGSvBkOAE]charmDate ScAm[/url] referees, The american producers along with perhaps the scattered scoreboard. the united states trainer Van Chancellor kommet at the particular dais, scouting around just as if he wish to be home in Mississippi. i never need to ask the european boor reasons why the size of his set would not foul in the end minutes, simply allow the USA run out the time inside a comparable pastime. who else might get a thing when it comes to edgewise. I selected might have preferred to listen to "Ivan wood" justify that many, unfortunately. 1992 females 10,000 metres extremely a person's gold medalist, Ethiopia's Derartu Tulu, won the gap marathon using a damaging punch on the bell clapboard. southern Africa's Elana meyer, in the summertime jogger to outstanding Tulu for many of the difficult six mls, finalized second. Tulu was ever each of our first dark colored african-american lady that can triumph in a sterling silver medal. meyer provides the first towards the south african-american in honor after place lso are stated competitor for the first time Olympic taking into consideration that for the programs 1960 racial apartheid. the actual wining panel most typically associated with meyer in addition to Tulu, racing next to each other, came as selling and after that superb as almost any moment in show off. 1992 of various bronze medal football game title in that case,perhaps deal the "more imagine producers, It hasn't been ones nba rigorous team, the real "aspire crew, which usually 1992 broken the age group of faculty manufacturers creating the united states sales team. another Dreamers could be from small Baltic proclaim associated Lithuania, birthplace in Cavaliers' financial situation beloved residence, Zydrunas Ilgauskas. using the bronze medal online, Lithuania beaten each of our "unified franchise, 82 78. Lithuania's challengers ended athletes about remnants as to Lithuania's oppressors the end battle II, some sort of Soviet partnership. the video game used to be watched within the small Ilgauskas and everyone attending [url=http://www.scoop.it/t/charmingdate-com-reviews-search]CHarmdate Scam[/url] getting tv in Lithuania, and in all likelihood by its pleased old. The band's part obtained the Lithuanians visit to the capital, meanwhile with the and the they can wear Deadhead tie up dyed warm-up tops. "We know we were holding observing, safeguard Sarunas Marciulionis agreed regarding your boyfriend's countrymen "we will knowledge all their hearts beating.

2016 olympics come from Rio CLEVELAND, iowa The 2016 olympics period his or her own beginning events Friday nighttime time in Rio l'ordre de Janeiro of this activities uneasy from trhe Zika virus as well pollution, but also right now impure by a vital doping scal. Among various players during places, a new Russians typically following! a few of them, anyways. particularly if the, those can pass examination through your sport's ruling human. the whole european info and service business is generally banned, about the other hand. The Russians recognized guilty by modern society stop Doping supplier (WADA) among executing a state financed doping app, players like which weren't regarded ever since the long, Unlamented far east indonesia doped at a balance may well have been the envy of the individual of huge cheaters of these people, bicyclist lance Armstrong. I sprayed seven olympics, Five summer months ones, Two winters. this one merely pays for itself since there is reader engag. any one very own quite Olympic recollections are almost always of natives, absurdly. i am a observe also area basketball game man, to my personal favorite Olympic sports fly, and so i will start off work on them. Butch [url=https://twitter.com/charmdate?lang=en]charmdate Scam[/url] Reynolds of all Akron Hoban and / or kentkucky tell you, The 400 metres business checklist plate the moment, or even be up against contorted in hurt, produced stomach fat keep going 100 yards in a history of the big event in Seoul in 1988, Only to settle for the an incredibly honor while he started besides progressively. Butch turned out to be optimal quarter miler on earth, with a Usain Bolt that include stride but decent energy. regretably, also, It has not been currently the Olympic 401 meters. on the other hand, Wesaintlake's and even. Ignatius's bob Mack approved the tavern in Athens in 2004 within a person of polish lineage vault on this man's third to the previous work for balance an Olympic proof your old watches honor being successful pinnacle associated with 19 feet, 6 1/4 inches tall. while i wrote the sunday paper, "above and beyond, over jacob. 2004 girls Olympic basketball semifinal however, many of your other top recollection will never be of locals, several not connected with the population. the main u. s citizens mothers, On the potency of a passionate, reduced fun, late competitive burst which is Sheryl Swoopes went under, performed through a ruskies rally, 66 62, interior semifinals in a holiday in greece. european inform Anatoly Myshkin crudely grabbed covering the news achieving after. He churlishly berated the particular [url=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6CSGSvBkOAE]charmDate ScAm[/url] referees, The american producers along with perhaps the scattered scoreboard. the united states trainer Van Chancellor kommet at the particular dais, scouting around just as if he wish to be home in Mississippi. i never need to ask the european boor reasons why the size of his set would not foul in the end minutes, simply allow the USA run out the time inside a comparable pastime. who else might get a thing when it comes to edgewise. I selected might have preferred to listen to "Ivan wood" justify that many, unfortunately. 1992 females 10,000 metres extremely a person's gold medalist, Ethiopia's Derartu Tulu, won the gap marathon using a damaging punch on the bell clapboard. southern Africa's Elana meyer, in the summertime jogger to outstanding Tulu for many of the difficult six mls, finalized second. Tulu was ever each of our first dark colored african-american lady that can triumph in a sterling silver medal. meyer provides the first towards the south african-american in honor after place lso are stated competitor for the first time Olympic taking into consideration that for the programs 1960 racial apartheid. the actual wining panel most typically associated with meyer in addition to Tulu, racing next to each other, came as selling and after that superb as almost any moment in show off. 1992 of various bronze medal football game title in that case,perhaps deal the "more imagine producers, It hasn't been ones nba rigorous team, the real "aspire crew, which usually 1992 broken the age group of faculty manufacturers creating the united states sales team. another Dreamers could be from small Baltic proclaim associated Lithuania, birthplace in Cavaliers' financial situation beloved residence, Zydrunas Ilgauskas. using the bronze medal online, Lithuania beaten each of our "unified franchise, 82 78. Lithuania's challengers ended athletes about remnants as to Lithuania's oppressors the end battle II, some sort of Soviet partnership. the video game used to be watched within the small Ilgauskas and everyone attending [url=http://www.scoop.it/t/charmingdate-com-reviews-search]CHarmdate Scam[/url] getting tv in Lithuania, and in all likelihood by its pleased old. The band's part obtained the Lithuanians visit to the capital, meanwhile with the and the they can wear Deadhead tie up dyed warm-up tops. "We know we were holding observing, safeguard Sarunas Marciulionis agreed regarding your boyfriend's countrymen "we will knowledge all their hearts beating.